What Should Big 12 Prioritize When Creating New Football Divisions?

Jan 18, 2022, 12:07 PM
Big 12 Conference Championship...
ARLINGTON, TX - DECEMBER 4: The Big 12 logo is seen on a pylon before the game between the Oklahoma State Cowboys and the Baylor Bears in the Big 12 Football Championship at AT&T Stadium on December 4, 2021 in Arlington, Texas. Baylor won 21-16.(Photo by Ron Jenkins/Getty Images)
(Photo by Ron Jenkins/Getty Images)

SALT LAKE CITY – The new Big 12 Conference that will include BYU, UCF, Cincinnati, and Houston will be a fascinating league. Unlike many of the Power Conference leagues, the new era of the Big 12 Conference will not have a set juggernaut to take down. That makes creating divisions even more fascinating.

Also, the geography spans three timezones from here in the Wasatch Front to Orlando and Morgantown, West Virginia. So there will be no shortage of intrigue surrounding this new iteration of the Big 12.

But those unique dynamics in this league make for a fascinating proposition, creating the new divisions.

Dennis Dodd from CBS Sports reported that the conference plans on a 14-team league starting in 2023. That will include Texas and Oklahoma until they bolt for the SEC in 2025 after their Grant of Rights is up.

So for this, we’re just focusing on the 12 teams that will shape the future of the Big 12 Conference. What should the university presidents and athletic directors inside the Big 12 Conference focus on when forming these new divisions?

Here are my thoughts.

Texas presence for everyone

Give everyone a presence in the state of Texas. Like the Pac-12, where everyone dips into California, the same should happen for the new Big 12.

I’m sure BYU, UCF, and Cincinnati (exclude Houston because they are already in Texas) are okay with any division they get because being in the Big 12 is a lot better than their current situations (Independence & AAC). But with a league centered in the Lone Star State, why not give everyone a robust annual presence to showcase their brands to the talent-rich state?

My divisions would feature two Texas teams in each division, splitting up the two biggest markets in Dallas-Fort Worth and Houston in two separate divisions.

Competitive balance

Competitive balance is where division formation gets tricky. There’s a great argument that 11 of these 12 teams (sorry, Kansas; we see you’re improving, though) could be the class of this conference in any given year. So for this exercise, I kept three founding Big 12 members (since 1996) in each division.

Then split up the two programs that joined this past decade in TCU and West Virginia and made an even split of the four newcomers.

Don’t worry about geography

Through this process with conference expansion, we’ve learned that many of the talking points people liked to regurgitate didn’t have much substance. For example, BYU’s “Sunday play” rule was not much of an issue at all in the process. Big 12 Commissioner Bob Bowlsby said it was “a consideration,” not a “concern.”

Another realignment talking point was “traveling partner for West Virginia.” That’s great in college basketball, which will likely have its own divisions. According to Big 12 Commissioner Bob Bowlsby, he had an interview with KSL Sports in October. But geography shouldn’t be viewed as a big deal in college football.

So I’d split the former Big East rivals Cincinnati and West Virginia into separate divisions. Then, they could have a semi-regular cross-division battle. Especially if the Big 12 goes with nine conference games.

When creating college football divisions, geography should be the least of anyone’s worries.

My proposed Big 12 Conference divisions for football

Division A



Iowa State

Oklahoma State


Texas Tech

Division B





Kansas State

West Virginia

Mitch Harper is a BYU Insider for and host of the Cougar Tracks Podcast (SUBSCRIBE) and Cougar Sports Saturday (Saturday from 12–3 p.m.) on KSL Newsradio. Follow him on Twitter: @Mitch_Harper.

  • BYU Cougars Scoreboard

  • BYU Cougars Team Leaders

  • BYU Cougars Standings

College Football

BYU Football - Chaz Ah You...
Mitch Harper

BYU Announces Spring Football Dates For 2022 Season

The start of Kalani Sitake's seventh year at BYU is just around the corner.
4 months ago
BYU Football - Campbell Barrington...
Mitch Harper

BYU Offensive Lineman Recognized As Freshman All-American

For the eighth time since 2001, BYU football has a Freshman All-American from the FWAA.
4 months ago
Jarinn Kalama...
Mitch Harper

Future BYU Football Players Are Well-Represented At 2022 Polynesian Bowl

Want to see some future BYU players in action this Saturday? They'll be competing in the 2022 Polynesian Bowl.
4 months ago
Utah Utes Football Helmet...
Trevor Allen

Utah Football Receives Commitment From JUCO Quarterback Luke Bottari

College of San Mateo quarterback Luke Bottari has committed to the Utah football program as a preferred walk-on.
4 months ago
BYU Football - Gunner Romney...
Dallen Graff

2022 Will Be The Year Of The Wide Receiver For BYU

Gunner Romney has a chance to cement his name in BYU record books and help his Cougars have a record-breaking season in 2022.
4 months ago
Big 12 Conference logo...
Mitch Harper

Big 12 Reportedly Planning For 14-Team League Beginning In 2023

Two seven-team divisions are expected to be coming to the Big 12 Conference.
4 months ago
What Should Big 12 Prioritize When Creating New Football Divisions?